Application and Hearing Procedures


 

A water right permit to appropriate water allows a person to make a private, beneficial use of a  public resource.  Any interested person is welcome to participate in the procedure used to process an application.  

 

The following is a brief summary of the application and hearing process:

 

South Dakota DENR logo bulletApplication Report and Recommendation

 

Upon receipt of a completed application for a water right permit, a report is prepared by the Water Rights Program.  In order for an application to be approved, the following conditions need to be met:

 

  • Reasonable probability that unappropriated water is available for the proposed use;
  • No unlawful impairment of existing water rights;
  • Must be a beneficial use of water; and
  • In the public interest

 

After completing a report, the chief engineer makes a recommendation as to whether the application should be approved, deferred, or denied.  Recommendations typically include one or more qualifications including certain restrictions, limitations, or other responsibilities for the applicant to fulfill.  A copy of the report and recommendation is provided to the applicant and anyone else is provided a copy upon request. 

 

 

South Dakota DENR logo bulletPublic Notice of Application for a Water Right Permit

 

Following completion of the report and recommendation, the applicant is responsible for publishing a notice in an official newspaper in the county or counties in which water is to be diverted or used or where project works will be located.  Notice is to be published once a week for two successive weeks.  The notice provides a brief description of the proposed water use project, the recommendation of the chief engineer, a statement of how to participate in a hearing on the application, as well as other procedural requirements.  Applications currently undergoing public notice may be viewed by clicking here.

 

 

South Dakota DENR logo bulletPetition to Intervene

 

In order to participate in a hearing on an application a written petition needs to be filed with the chief engineer and the applicant by the date specified in the published notice.  The applicant does not need to file a petition.  A petition to support or oppose an application may be informal but needs to include the following information:

 

  • A statement describing your interest in the application;
  • The reasons for opposition to or support for the application; and
  • Your signature and mailing address or that of your legal counsel.

 

 

South Dakota DENR logo bulletContested Case Hearing

 

If an application or the recommendation of the chief engineer is contested, then a contested case hearing is scheduled for the Water Management Board to consider the application and recommendation during a board meeting.  The Water Management Board is a quasi-judicial citizen's board consisting of seven members appointed by the Governor.  During a contested case hearing the board will consider the evidence presented by all the interested parties including the applicant, petitioners, and the staff of the Water Rights Program.   A contested case hearing may be very formal or informal.  Individuals may represent themselves or all parties may be represented by legal counsel, present testimony and evidence to the board, call witnesses to testify, and cross-examine other parties or their witnesses. 

 

 

South Dakota DENR logo bulletFinal Decision on an Application for a Water Right Permit

 

After considering all the evidence presented during a contested case hearing, the board may approve, modify, or deny the application or the board may choose to delay making a final decision pending receipt of additional information.  Once a decision is made by the board, then typically the board's attorney will prepare "findings of fact, conclusions of law, and a final decision" for the board and all parties to review.  Following a comment period on the proposed "findings, conclusions, and final decision," the board will conduct a hearing to adopt the findings, conclusions, and final decision.  These "findings" provide a written record of the issues considered by the board and the board's responses and reasons for the final decision.  This written record is necessary since decisions of the board may be appealed to Circuit Court and the State Supreme Court.